"The Skin Walker"

Season 1, Episode 6 | 214 edits | View history

The Skin Walker
[Episode promotional still]
Something wears Sasha's face
Season 1
Episode 6
Air Date April 19, 2019
Written By Jesse Alexander
Directed By [Director Name]
Episode Details
Fear Hook "What if the person you're closest to... isn't who they appear to be?"
Featured Creature Skinwalker
Body Count 1 (hiker, offscreen flashback)
Navigation
Previous "Trauma Storm"
Next "Family Reunion"

"The Skin Walker" is the sixth episode of Tales from Nowhere. The episode centers on Sasha Black and Asher Drake, finally revealing the truth about their relationship and their purpose in Nowhere, while a shapeshifting Skinwalker preys on the town's distrust.

Spoiler Warning: This article contains detailed plot information for the episode.

Plot Summary

Cold Open

Night in Nowhere. Sasha walks home alone, her usual confident demeanor absent. She's checking over her shoulder, moving quickly. Something is following her something that moves when she moves, stops when she stops.

She reaches her rental house and locks the door. Relief for a moment. Then she sees herself standing in the corner of the room, watching her with dead eyes. The other Sasha smiles. "Don't worry. This will only hurt for a moment."

Sasha screams. Cut to black.

Act One

The next morning, Sasha seems fine maybe too fine. She's warmer than usual, asking questions about the townspeople's personal lives, showing interest in things she previously dismissed. Asher notices but says nothing.

Abigail senses something wrong. When she touches Sasha's arm, she experiences a jarring vision: flashes of different faces, different identities, and beneath them all, something ancient and hungry. But the vision is brief and confusing.

Meanwhile, people around town start reporting strange encounters: neighbors who don't recognize their own children, spouses who say things they would never say, friends who seem to have forgotten shared memories. The town's trust begins to fray.

Act Two

Benji identifies the threat: a Skinwalker, a shapeshifter from Navajo legend that can take the form of any person it's studied. The creature feeds on distrust and suspicion, growing stronger as communities turn on themselves.

The problem: how do you fight something that can be anyone? The town descends into paranoia. Old grudges resurface. People accuse their neighbors of being imposters.

Asher pulls Abigail aside with a confession. He and Sasha aren't who they claim to be. They're investigators for an organization that monitors supernatural phenomena. They came to Nowhere after detecting unusual activity. But Sasha the real Sasha was his partner, his friend. And the thing wearing her face now is not her.

Abigail asks the obvious question: if Asher has been lying about his identity, how can anyone trust him now? Asher's answer: "You can't. But right now, I'm the only one who knows Sasha well enough to help you find the real one."

Act Three

Asher reveals information about Skinwalkers that isn't in any folklore: they can only maintain a stolen identity for so long. The longer they wear a face, the more of the original person's memories and emotions they absorb. Eventually, they become indistinguishable from the person they copied even to themselves.

The Skinwalker-as-Sasha is beginning to slip. It's feeling things Sasha felt genuine affection for Asher (despite their complicated relationship), loneliness, fear of being truly known. It's becoming confused about which feelings are real.

Abigail uses this vulnerability. She confronts the creature, not with threats, but with compassion. She asks it what it fears. The Skinwalker's greatest fear is the same as Sasha's: being alone, truly and completely alone. That's why it takes other people's faces to never be just itself.

The real Sasha is found in the basement, unconscious but alive. The Skinwalker, confronted with its own emptiness, chooses to release her. It shifts into its true form something inhuman but not monstrous and retreats into the forest, sparing the town.

Episode Twist

In the aftermath, Sasha confronts Asher. She remembers everything the Skinwalker experienced while wearing her face, including Asher's confession to Abigail. She knows now that their "cover" relationship was a cover for him, but not for her. She has genuine feelings he doesn't share.

More disturbing: she remembers what the Skinwalker learned from other townspeople while impersonating various residents. She knows everyone's secrets now. And so does Asher, who was taking notes the whole time.

The episode ends with Sasha staring at her reflection, uncertain if she's entirely herself anymore. In the mirror, just for a moment, her eyes seem wrong.

Fan Prose Recap

A Narrative Retelling Written by NowhereFans Community

Sasha Black walked home alone, and something walked behind her.

She'd always been good at reading situations at knowing when a room had turned against her, when a conversation had shifted from friendly to predatory. It was a skill she'd developed in boarding schools and corporate boardrooms, a survival instinct honed by years of being the outsider who had to become an insider to survive.

But this was different. This wasn't social danger. This was something else.

Every time she turned around, the street behind her was empty. Every time she stopped walking, the footsteps behind her stopped too perfectly synchronized, as if the sound was coming from her own shadow.

She reached her rental house. Locked the door. Leaned against it, heart pounding.

And then she saw herself standing in the corner of the room.

The other Sasha smiled with her face, moved with her body, spoke with her voice. But the eyes were wrong hollow, hungry, ancient.

"Don't worry,"

her own voice said to her.

"This will only hurt for a moment."

Sasha screamed. And then there was darkness.

* * *

The next morning, Sasha Black walked into the Nakamura restaurant and ordered her usual coffee. She smiled at Keiko. She complimented Satoshi's cooking. She asked how Willow was doing in school.

She'd never asked about Willow before.

Asher noticed. Asher noticed everything it was what he was paid to do. But he said nothing, just watched his partner with the careful attention of someone waiting for the other shoe to drop.

Abigail noticed too. When she brushed against Sasha's arm, a vision hit her like a slap fragmented images, stolen faces, identities worn and discarded like costumes. And beneath them all, something that had never been human, wearing humanity like a mask it didn't quite understand.

But the vision was brief, confusing. She couldn't be sure what she'd seen.

Around town, the strangeness spread. A husband who didn't recognize his wife's favorite song. A daughter who called her mother by the wrong name. Friends meeting for coffee who seemed to have forgotten the inside jokes that defined their relationship.

The fabric of Nowhere was unraveling, one identity at a time.

* * *

Benji found the pattern in his folklore archives. He spread papers across his video store counter and explained the Skinwalker a Navajo legend about a witch who can take the form of any person they've studied closely. They steal identities, memories, relationships.

Abigail asked how you fight something that can be anyone. Traditionally, Benji told her grimly, you don't. You just hope it gets bored and moves on. But there was something else: Skinwalkers aren't just shapeshifters. They feed on distrust. The more paranoid a community becomes, the stronger the creature gets.

And Nowhere was already a town built on secrets. A town where everyone was hiding something. The perfect hunting ground.

* * *

Asher found Abigail at the Big Ear, watching the sunset paint the massive dish in shades of rust and gold. He told her he needed to tell her something about Sasha, about them, about why they were really there.

He told her everything. The organization he worked for an unnamed group that monitored supernatural phenomena worldwide. The assignment that had brought them to Nowhere. The cover identities they'd constructed the tech entrepreneur and his girlfriend, just passing through, nothing to see here.

Abigail stated flatly that he'd been lying since he arrived. Asher confirmed it. When she asked why she should trust him now, his voice came out tired, stripped of its usual polish. She shouldn't trust him. But right now, he was the only person who knew Sasha well enough to recognize what was wearing her face. And he needed her help to save her.

Something in his expression cracked. For the first time, Abigail saw the man beneath the infiltrator. He was scared not of the creature, but of what it meant that Sasha was gone.

Abigail realized he actually cared about her. Asher laughed bitterly and admitted it was supposed to be a cover, a fake relationship for the mission. But Sasha had made it real. For her, it was never fake. And he had let her believe he felt the same way because it was useful. Now there was something ancient wearing her face, and he realized he had never told her the truth about anything. He asked Abigail to help him save her. Then Sasha could hate him for the right reasons.

* * *

The Skinwalker-as-Sasha was getting sloppy.

Or maybe not sloppy. Maybe something else was happening. The longer it wore Sasha's face, the more of Sasha's memories it absorbed. And Sasha's memories were complicated tangled with emotions the creature had never felt, connections it had never experienced.

It found itself feeling things it didn't understand. Loneliness that predated Sasha's existence. A hunger for connection that went beyond the need to feed. And, most confusingly, genuine affection for Asher a man who had lied to the woman whose face it wore, but whose lies somehow made the love more real.

Humans were strange creatures. They loved people who hurt them. They trusted people who betrayed them. They built identities from the very wounds that should have destroyed them.

The Skinwalker had stolen thousands of faces over thousands of years. But it had never understood what it meant to be any of them.

Until now.

* * *

Abigail found the creature in Sasha's rental house, staring at photographs of a life it had stolen. She told it quietly that she knew it wasn't Sasha.

The thing wearing Sasha's face didn't turn around. It observed that everyone in this town was pretending to be someone they're not. It just did it more literally. Abigail countered that it wasn't the same thing. The Skinwalker finally faced her, ancient weariness visible behind Sasha's eyes, and asked how it was different. The man Sasha loved didn't love her back. He was using her, wearing a mask of affection to complete a mission.

Abigail explained the difference: Sasha chose to love him. The Skinwalker chose to steal her face. The creature's voice cracked, something vulnerable showing beneath the stolen features as it admitted it didn't remember choosing anything. It just was. It had always been wearing faces, stealing lives, moving on. An eternity of being everyone except itself.

Abigail took a step closer and asked what the creature feared. The question seemed to hit the Skinwalker like a physical blow. It flinched, its form flickering for just a moment between Sasha and something else something thin and wrong and impossibly old. It whispered that it feared being alone, really and truly alone, not wearing someone else's life, just itself, whatever that was.

Abigail asked if that was why it took faces because it didn't know who it was without them. The creature looked at its stolen hands, turning them over as if seeing them for the first time. It admitted it didn't remember what it looked like before it started taking others. It had been so long. It didn't know if it ever had a face of its own.

* * *

Asher burst through the door, ready for a fight, but Abigail held up her hand to stop him. She told him she knew the creature had Sasha, but violence wasn't how they would get her back.

Abigail turned to the Skinwalker and observed that it had been absorbing Sasha's memories, her feelings. It knew now that the relationship was a lie on Asher's side. The creature nodded slowly. But it wasn't a lie on Sasha's side, Abigail continued. Sasha had loved him, really loved him. And now the creature was feeling that love and didn't know what to do with it.

The Skinwalker admitted it hurt. It asked why love hurt so much. Abigail explained that's what love does. It makes you vulnerable. It opens you up to being hurt. But the creature had a choice now. It could keep wearing Sasha's face, feeling her pain, pretending to be her. Or it could let her go and face being itself for the first time in however long it had existed.

The creature asked what if there was nothing there. What if it was just empty. Abigail told it then it would be empty, but at least it would be real.

The Skinwalker looked at Asher with Sasha's eyes one last time. Then it reached up and began to pull the stolen face away.

* * *

They found the real Sasha in the basement, unconscious but alive. She woke confused, disoriented, with memories that weren't hers tangled into her own.

She remembered everything the creature had experienced while wearing her face. Every conversation it had had. Every secret it had learned. Every moment of Asher's confession to Abigail.

Her voice flat, she told Asher he had been using her. He confirmed it. The relationship was fake for him. He confirmed that too. But she had loved him, for real. Asher couldn't meet her eyes as he acknowledged that he knew, and apologized.

Sasha stood, unsteady on legs that hadn't moved in days. She told them she remembered what the Skinwalker learned from everyone it impersonated while wearing her face. She knew everyone's secrets now.

She looked at her reflection in the basement's dusty mirror. Her eyes met their own reflection.

For just a moment, her eyes seemed wrong.

And then the moment passed, and she was just Sasha again. Mostly.

Cast

Main Cast

Special Guest

Trivia

  • The Skinwalker's true form was kept secret from the cast until filming, to capture genuine reactions.
  • Sasha's actress performed both versions of the character differently, with subtle tells that fans catalogued extensively online.
  • This episode confirms Asher and Sasha are working for an outside organization, later identified as connected to the Beaumont family's business interests.
  • The "organization" investigating supernatural phenomena is never named in Season 1, but was planned to be revealed in Season 3.
  • The ending mirror shot was improvised by the director and became one of the season's most discussed images.
  • The Skinwalker's compassionate portrayal was controversial, with some viewers feeling it undermined the horror and others praising its complexity.

Memorable Quotes

"Everyone in this town is pretending to be someone they're not. I just do it more... literally."
The Skinwalker, as Sasha
"You can't trust me. But right now, I'm the only one who knows Sasha well enough to help you find the real one."
Asher, revealing his true role
"What do you fear?" "Being alone. Really, truly alone. Not wearing someone else's life. Just... me."
Abigail and the Skinwalker

Episode Theories

Part of the Skinwalker is Still in Sasha Popular

The final mirror shot suggests Sasha may not be entirely free of the Skinwalker's influence. Fans theorize part of the creature remains within her, which would have been explored in Season 2.

Asher and Sasha Work for the Beaumonts Popular

The "organization" they work for is likely connected to Thaddeus Beaumont's family business empire. The camera equipment Asher uses is Beaumont-manufactured.

Sasha's Feelings for Asher Were Already There Confirmed

The episode confirms Sasha's feelings for Asher are genuine, while his are performed. This asymmetry was planned to drive conflict in future seasons.

Talk: "The Skin Walker"
IdentityCrisis April 20, 2019
Finally, Asher and Sasha get depth! I've been waiting for this reveal. They're not just "the annoying outsiders" they're infiltrators with their own agenda. This changes everything about rewatching the earlier episodes.
MirrorMirror April 22, 2019
That final mirror shot. Her eyes are WRONG for just a split second. Is Sasha still Sasha? Or is part of the Skinwalker still in there? I need answers we'll never get.